9 Magical Harry Potter Things to do in NYC

Accio Potterhead!

If you are a Potterhead, looking for Harry Potter things to do in NYC, then you’ve come to the right place!

When we think of Harry Potter in the USA, the first that comes to mind is generally the Wizarding World of Harry Potter at Universal Studios, but that’s not all there is!

Harry Potter in NYC isn’t a rarity since the books and movies are still hugely popular in the whole of the US and as we know, New York City is the theatre capital of America.

Harry Potter has a strong following in NYC. There is even a fan group that exists with 3000 members, called “Harry Potter NYC – The Group that Shall Not be Named” and they check out the best Harry Potter experiences in New York City.

But you don’t have to be part of the group to discover the best Harry Potter places in New York. We are here to tell you everything about them!

So, pack your broom and let’s explore the Big Apple Harry Potter version!

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no extra cost for you!

Harry Potter things to do in NYC

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child NYC

Harry Potter and the cursed Child in New York

Let’s start with the most obvious and best Harry Potter activity in New York City: the Harry Potter and Cursed Child play.

As you probably know, Harry Potter didn’t end with the Deathly Hallows. In 2016, J.K. Rowling released another part of the story (once Harry, Hermione and Ron have kids).

This book was different from the others as it’s not a novel but a play.  

It was later on adapted so every Potterhead can see it live! It premiered in London at the Palace theatre but is also available in New York City!

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child NYC is an iconic 2-part play written by J.K. Rowling, John Tiffany and Jack Thorne is a Broadway show running at the Lyric Theatre NYC… The show is so well made, award-winning, mesmerizing, filled with theatrical magic and has great critic reviews.  

As I swore to “keep secrets” I won’t be telling you too much about it but it is really awesome! The special effects are fantastic and the actors great! By the time the first part finishes, you will be so impatient to see the second one that you will have a hard time waiting!  

For a Harry Potter fan, the show is completely worth it but even if HP is not your thing, you can only love the play. It’s so well done!  

Harry Potter Broadway tickets NYC are available on the website and through a ticketing agency. They generally don’t have the same availability so it’s worth checking both.

That way you make sure to see everything.

The tickets are available on a first-come-first-serve basis. You can buy them in person, call the New York Lyric Theatre and book and there are group booking plans available as well.  

That being said, the play is extremely popular and sells out very fast! Sometimes up to 6 months in advance. For that reason, I highly recommend that you book in advance and online. It’s very hard to get them last minute and they can be very expensive.

To avoid any disappointments, booking online will be your best shot.

Harry Potter on Broadway is one of the best Harry Potter experiences in New York and you are going to love it!  

Click here to see the latest prices and availability.

Harry Potter Store on Broadway

Harry Potter Store in New York

The Harry Potter Store in New York City is a fairyland for Potter-lovers because it is not just a store, it is a huge dream sequence in itself!  

Warner Bros opened a huge Harry Potter store in NYC in 2020 and that is something you cannot miss.

It’s located between the 5th ave and Broadway but the entrance can be found at 935 Broadway. It’s only 1 minute walk from the Flatiron Building and Madison Square Park so it’s very easy to get there.

Harry Potter Store on Broadway NYC
Harry Potter Shop on Broadway NYC

The Harry Potter store NYC is the largest store dedicated to the young wizard and other characters in the world.

It may not be as good as visiting the Harry Potter Studios in London but it’s definitely well worth a visit.

Whether you are a Gryffindor, Slytherin, Ravenclaw or Hufflepuff, the Harry Potter store is something to behold.

Harry Potter store statues NYC
Harry Potter store statues NYC

Apart from amazing Harry Potter merchandise, the store has infinite interactive experiences and millions of photo opportunities which can prove to be a treat for fans.

The perfect Harry Potter Instagram spot in New York!

Every Potterhead will love visiting the Harry Potter NYC store to buy authentic merch and have a lot of nothing but Pure Magic!

PRO TIP: If you have any Harry Potter-themed outfits, it will be the perfect time to take them out since you’ll take loads of photos there.

Butterbeer Bar

butterbeer bar in NYC

Want to try a real butterbeer? Then the Butterbeer bar right by the Harry Potter store will be the perfect place for you.

While you can find loads of ‘butterbeer’ in the city, the only place where you can actually buy and drink a real butterbeer is at the butterbeer bar.

Wall at the butterbeer bar in NYC

The recipe of the butterbeer is secret and only official Harry Potter places know it and can sell it. This means that there are only a handful of places in the world where you can find them.

You can find bottled butterbeer in the store but if you want to have a true muggle experience, head straight to the butterbeer bar.

There is an actual bar serving it in cute glasses. It’s very well decorated and feels so magical.

Harry Potter bars in NYC

harry potter cauldron NYC

Harry Potter theme bars can be a great idea to enjoy some boozy evenings, Potter style.   If you want to give Butterbeers and Fire Whiskeys a go, visit The Cauldron.  

This magical little bar located in the financial district of Manhattan is a must-see for any HP fan!

The look and feel of the bar are complete with shady corners, a fake tree in the centre with a wizard guarding it and interesting drink options.

There are working wands which act as beer tabs. The wands can be tapped on the taps placed around the tree and the beer would pour! Also, there is a potions workshop area on the second floor.  

The Cauldron is a famous chain of Harry Potter bars and also exist in London, Dublin and Edinburgh!   Going to the Cauldron is the perfect Harry Potter experience in New York City.

They also offer a “Supper & Spells” menu that includes 2 mains, potion making and spell casting!

If you want to have a Harry Potter afternoon in NYC, you should consider booking a potion-making workshop! It’s a pretty cool thing to do and you can take many great photos!

You can also visit Barcelona Bar which has a Harry Potter lookalike bartender and sets the shots on fire using his real and working wand!  

Harry Potter Restaurants in New York

A certain café called Steamy Hallows is located in East Village serving Harry Potter themes hot and cold beverages and snacks.

This is a cosy little place, ideal for grabbing a hot magical mug of chocolate or some smartly made snacks. It is a small café, just about enough to rest your mug and snack, take a swig and take off rather than sit down, linger and drink.

Even the servers are in houses and ask which one are you in before serving you! Please note, this is a popup cafe.

If you want to find the original, you will need to head to Pennsylvania!   In Brooklyn, a pasta restaurant based on the Harry Potter theme has opened up. It’s called Pasta Wiz.

The hall is designed to look like the great hall at Hogwarts and the food is also inspired, like, Magical meatballs and Dragon’s Blood smoothie.

A sorting hat sits on the counter and you can get your dish in under 5 minutes. There are plenty of vegan and organic options too.  

Harry Potter Escape Rooms in NYC

The best Harry Potter escape room is located in St Jones, New York where the players have to break out of Azkaban and return to the school.

There is another task to collect the Horcruxes in an hour and defeat Voldemort. The fun exercise is engaging for the whole family. This one is called Harry Potter Escape.  

There is another in Buffalo, New York called The Wizard’s Keep, wherein the game begins with you being sorted into a house and then being given an hour’s worth of puzzles and riddles to solve. This can be played in a team of 4 people to 8 people.

These escape rooms also offer digital versions! Wander through Hogwarts and have your own adventure.

The digital escape room in NYC gives you a lot of riddles and puzzles to solve, while there is social distancing in play.  

Harry Potter Trivia in New York City

Trivia nights happen in NYC around the Harry Potter theme regularly. The details of this are posted on social media.

They can be attended for some extended fun, even more importantly, as ways to connect with other Potterheads as well as do some cosplay!  

Harry Potter Brunch NYC

This happened on one weekend in May 2019 at Pier60 in NYC, where hundreds of people enjoyed the scrumptious themed meals in the day and night.

The entertainment and food combo is held in various cities like Denver, Colorado, and Houston, TX in the US and also Melbourne, Australia and Liverpool, England. It is an amazing event to attend for even the shyest Potterhead.  

Puffs the play in New York

The Puffs play in NYC is a hilarious and innocent play, a must-watch for a Potterhead.  

The play is jovial, fun and revolves around the Hufflepuffs, the most underrated house in Hogwarts.  

While Harry was doing heroic deeds, the Hufflepuffs were adding to the charm in a harmless way.  

The lovable people in this house and how they survived all the school years makes for an endearing story.  

Unfortunately, this play showed last in 2019. But if it happens again, it will be a treat to the viewer! Stay tuned!  

With all these Harry Potter things to do in NYC, you should keep yourself busy for a long time! If that’s not enough for you, you should check the other Harry Potter locations in the world! There are so many!  

You may also be interested in: